A year-round shop dedicated to mysterious phenomena

We have the LARGEST selection of mysterious phenomena products than anyone else on this block, way more than the barber shop next door

Store News:

Merry Christmas!! I hope everyone is well and happy. For the rest of the year we are celebrating our 20% off promotion for all Bigfoot and cryptid merchandise.

We will be closed New Year's Day and Tuesday, January 6th

Is this one of those costume pop-up stores?

Hell no! We don't sell costumes. Halloween Everlasting is a shop devoted to UFOs, Bigfoot, Time Travel, and all other types of mysterious phenomena, and we do have a dedicated Halloween section.

We sell books about mysterious things, and we also sell spooky novelties, haunting jewelry, phenomena decor, and more! Don't forget the "more"!!

Look at all our stuff!!

AND MORE!!

Tarot, Ouija, Cryptids, Out of Body, Nazca Lines, Ancient Structures - all kinds of stuff related to mysterious things

Dr. Watson Fuzzy-Wuzzy

Owner and CEO of Halloween Everlasting (only at the shop on Saturdays), seen here helping me turn a 1,000 piece puzzle into a 980 piece puzzle.

Come visit the shop! There are three options for parking. 1) a couple of street spots immediately in front of the store. 2) Pass the store and there is a street one building down, make a right, then a quick right for a free parking field. 3) Drive to Massapequa, NY and park on any public street, then walk to the Massapequa train station and take the Long Island Railroad to Penn Station in NYC, from there, take the subway to LaGuardia Airport. Then take Spirit Airlines to Arnold Palmer Regional Airport, then take an uber to the shop!

Pay with all major credit / debit cards, cash, or Venmo

917 W. Crawford Ave Connellsville, PA 15425

724-603-3900

Sunday closed Monday 10-4 Tuesday 10-4 Wednesday 10-4 Thursday 10-4 Friday 10-4 Saturday 10-2